Controversy over security cameras
Pat McDonald
Issue date: 4/8/09 Section: Viewpoint
"Big Brother is watching," remarked one student when the topic of cameras being installed in the entrances of certain dorms on the Assumption College campus came up in a casual conversation recently. The news that the College is thinking of installing cameras inside a handful of dorms for next year has quickly become a hot topic of conversation among many students around the school and has jokingly been referred to as CameraGate, in honor of Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots "SpyGate" drama.
The plan calls for entranceway cameras in Plough, South, West and the LLC. Opinions range from staunch support of the new measure to ultimate disdain for the proposed plan. In an age of increased government presence intruding on the private lives of citizens, this may seem just another attempt by the powers-that-be to assert their control and presence among the student population at Assumption. With college funding going to increased police patrols and now the installation of cameras, many students worry that Assumption is quickly becoming a place where the students are no longer trusted and their privacy is intruded upon. Whether or not this is true, I feel that the cameras may in fact serve some good for the community.
An important aspect of this plan is the actual function the cameras would be serving. The proposed plan is not simply a feeble attempt by those in charge to control our lives as students at Assumption College. My reasoning for this belief results from the fact that these cameras would be installed in order to offer another layer of support for the Assumption College police in preventing crimes from happening on campus. Though some may be skeptical, these cameras will in fact serve the purpose of keeping the students safe on campus by keeping an eye on events going on around the entrances to buildings. These cameras would give the police a point of view they would not normally have had in previous circumstances.
"When would the cameras ever have to be used?" some students have asked. Most likely, and hopefully, they will never have to be used to fulfill their purpose in any extreme circumstance. However, an incident reported on the Assumption Public Safety webpage details a situation where an unnamed male attempted to get into a building posing as a "maintenance worker." In situations such as this, these cameras would be useful in capturing an image of the aforementioned person and hopefully lead to a subsequent arrest. Also, some incidents have arisen on weekend nights where desk workers have had trouble with students and guests; incidents have occurred where those responsible acted in a hostile manner, but have been able to leave before anything could be done. In situations such as these, cameras would have provided a useful tool for helping to identify anyone responsible for unwanted behavior.
The plan calls for entranceway cameras in Plough, South, West and the LLC. Opinions range from staunch support of the new measure to ultimate disdain for the proposed plan. In an age of increased government presence intruding on the private lives of citizens, this may seem just another attempt by the powers-that-be to assert their control and presence among the student population at Assumption. With college funding going to increased police patrols and now the installation of cameras, many students worry that Assumption is quickly becoming a place where the students are no longer trusted and their privacy is intruded upon. Whether or not this is true, I feel that the cameras may in fact serve some good for the community.
An important aspect of this plan is the actual function the cameras would be serving. The proposed plan is not simply a feeble attempt by those in charge to control our lives as students at Assumption College. My reasoning for this belief results from the fact that these cameras would be installed in order to offer another layer of support for the Assumption College police in preventing crimes from happening on campus. Though some may be skeptical, these cameras will in fact serve the purpose of keeping the students safe on campus by keeping an eye on events going on around the entrances to buildings. These cameras would give the police a point of view they would not normally have had in previous circumstances.
"When would the cameras ever have to be used?" some students have asked. Most likely, and hopefully, they will never have to be used to fulfill their purpose in any extreme circumstance. However, an incident reported on the Assumption Public Safety webpage details a situation where an unnamed male attempted to get into a building posing as a "maintenance worker." In situations such as this, these cameras would be useful in capturing an image of the aforementioned person and hopefully lead to a subsequent arrest. Also, some incidents have arisen on weekend nights where desk workers have had trouble with students and guests; incidents have occurred where those responsible acted in a hostile manner, but have been able to leave before anything could be done. In situations such as these, cameras would have provided a useful tool for helping to identify anyone responsible for unwanted behavior.
Be the first to comment on this story